If you are looking for a winter certified all-season tire that provides you with a good level of comfort and a quiet ride, Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive vs Bridgestone WeatherPeak deserve your attention!
Discover how both of these models compare, created by renowned manufacturers, presented by blackcircles Canada.
How do Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive vs Bridgestone WeatherPeak tires compare?
These names don’t ring a bell? Don’t worry, that’s normal! They are both models that arrived on the market in 2022. Less known than other renowned models, they still both offer cutting-edge technologies and offer excellent versatility.
In fact, these winter certified all-season tires are popular among buyers who don’t want to go through the hassle of having two different sets of tires. But finding tires in this category that offer high performance levels can sometimes be challenging!
When it comes to Pirelli, the Scorpion WeatherActive is exclusive to crossovers, SUVs and light trucks. It offers dimensions ranging between 17- and 22- inches. This means that sedan and coupé drivers will have to turn to the Cinturato WeatherActive.
As for the WeatherPeak, it is made mostly for sedans and minivans. It is available in several dimensions ranging from 15- to 20- inches, which means that they are suitable to several models.
Visually, it is easy to tell both tire models apart, given that the two manufacturers have approached the design differently. The Pirelli tire focuses on a directional tread for better resistance to aquaplaning and maximum traction performance.
As for the Bridgestone tire, it boasts a directional tread that helps improve comfort levels and ensure remarkable durability. These attributes already set the stage for what each tire model focuses on in terms of its main features. Below, you will find more details regarding actual performance levels, but first and foremost, find out more about their specs.
Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive: Specs
With the Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive tire, you will enjoy the following features, among others:
- A directional tread, for better aquaplaning resistance
The tread design with V- shaped grooves helps evacuate water efficiently and very quickly. This technical feature allows the tire to provide you with maximum traction on wet roads, when you are out on a rainy day or when the snow begins to melt in the spring. There are also lateral grooves that are shaped like trumpets, which also help with better water evacuation out and away from under the tire.
- A quiet driving experience
Pirelli has obviously thought of more than water evacuation; the block design was created to help reduce noise from forming within the tire. While driving, the transition between the blocks is smooth. Moreover, the void ratio in the shoulder contributes to making it even quieter. Compared to its competitors, it manages to reduce noise levels by 2 dB.
- An all-season compound with a mixture of resin and polymer
Thanks to the innovative tread compound, the tire is both flexible in cold temperatures and durable when it’s warm; a compound that also contributes to the versatility it offers, thanks to a wider temperature range! This also means that the tire offers great performance on wet road surfaces.
- Deep sipes
Equipped with gripping sipes, the tire literally grips onto the road when it is slippery or unstable like, for example, on water or snow. Thanks to their depth, these sipes offer performance levels that will last for a long time. In fact, 66 % of sipes are still visible even after 90 % of wear.
Moreover, the zigzag shaped central groove contributes to both water evacuation and traction performance on all types of roads.
- A 3- rib treadblock design
In order to offer a more durable tire, Pirelli also focuses on a 3- rib treadblock design which improves the tread rigidity.
Bridgestone WeatherPeak: Specs
Another model that was launched recently, the Bridgestone WeatherPeak tire has quickly stood out with advanced features, such as:
- Full-depth 3D sipes
Just like the Pirelli tire, the Bridgestone tire focuses on gripping sipes to offer safe and stable road handling in harsher road conditions. They provide you with maximum grip levels on the snow and help preserve performance levels over a long time thanks to a good depth.
- Evolving sipes and snow vices
Located in the central grooves, these evolving sipes improve snow compaction and quick water circulation. They ensure both tread rigidity and the tire’s stability levels on slippery surfaces, for a predictable steering response.
- Wide shoulder blocks with notches
The block width helps contribute to good stability while cornering, for a controlled and reassuring driving experience at all times. Moreover, the shoulders also have open slits that help with better water evacuation out and away from the tire surface, providing you with good traction on wet road surfaces.
- Wide circumferential grooves
With the four circumferential grooves and the lateral grooves, the Bridgestone tire provides you with a truly safe driving experience on wet roads. It evacuates water efficiently and provides you with added traction on the snow or slush.
All in all, this is a tire with a durable tread that is designed to provide you with a confident feeling at the wheel, in any season. Just like the 3PMSF symbol certifies, this all-season tire meets with the requirements needed for winter driving. Furthermore, you will enjoy a comfortable driving experience with good road handling at all times.
Choosing between the Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive and the Bridgestone WeatherPeak
As you have seen, you are dealing with two recent models that focus on the latest technological advancements in the tire industry. No matter your decision, you can expect quality! But in this Pirelli Scorpion WeatherActive vs Bridgestone WeatherPeak duel, which is the best tire for you?
The tread design clearly shows that Pirelli truly focuses on performance and aquaplaning resistance, while Bridgestone focuses more on comfort and durability.
In fact, tests completed with the Pirelli tire show that this tire is completely comfortable on wet road surfaces. Traction levels on wet roads are certainly among the best of its category. It also provides you with short braking distances, both on wet and dry roads.
Although braking distances are a little longer than for the Pirelli tire, the Bridgestone WeatherPeak tire still remains efficient on wet roads thanks to the groove design and the flexible compound. It also provides you with good accelerations and short braking distances in the snow.
On this note, it compares favorably to the best of its category; according to in-house testing, it even offers braking distances on snow covered roads that are 9.1 m shorter than the competition! This is a quality that it owes mostly to its full-depth 3D sipes.
Both tires offer an outstanding lifespan that is superior to several of their competitors in the winter certified all-season tire category. However, Bridgestone seems to have a slight advantage.
In fact, the WeatherPeak is covered by a 110,000 km warranty on tread life. Moreover, you will take advantage of the Platinum Pact Limited Warranty and a 90- day satisfaction guarantee.
When it comes to the WeatherActive, you will take advantage of the Pirelli Confidence Plan, which includes a 30- day satisfaction guarantee, along with a 100,000 km limited warranty on tread life.
As you can see, Bridgestone offers a little more, but this difference is also noticeable in the price, which is slightly higher for this model. The warranty and price are definitely elements that can influence your decision. But for both models, they balance each other out.
Comparing road handling
According to a comparison that was completed by Top Tire Review and that compared the Cinturato WeatherActive (the sedan version of the Scorpion WeatherActive) and the Bridgestone WeatherPeak, both offered very similar levels of performance when it comes to maneuverability and a quiet and high-quality driving experience.
Bridgestone, however, focuses on a smoother and more comfortable driving experience, while Pirelly chose to focus on greater performance levels. In fact, the latter is truly impressive while cornering, offering precise road handling and a feeling of control behind the wheel! As for the Bridgestone tire, it is known for the refined and quiet driving experience it offers, worthy of luxury vehicles.
Between these two high performance models that are also comfortable and quiet, which will you choose? Regardless of your final decision, you should know that blackcircles offers the best prices on the market.
